MVP Pulled Chicken Nachos

The first time I made these nachos for my Super Bowl party, my friend Sarah actually stood guard by the oven until they came out. She said she could smell the spices from the backyard and wasn't taking any chances on missing the first bite. That's when I knew this recipe was something special.

Last summer, my teenage nephew and I had a nacho competition at our family reunion. He went full gourmet with fancy toppings, but everyone kept coming back to my platter. He still won't admit defeat, but the empty pan spoke louder than words.

Ingredients

• Chicken breasts: Starting with raw chicken here instead of rotisserie gives you control over the spice level, but honestly, a store-bought rotisserie works beautifully on busy weeknights.
• Smoked paprika: This is the secret weapon that gives the chicken that authentic smoky flavor, almost like it came off a smoker.
• Thick-cut tortilla chips: Trust me on this one—thin chips turn into soggy disappointments under all those toppings.
• Two-cheese blend: Cheddar brings the sharpness while Monterey Jack adds that perfect melt factor.
• Fresh toppings: Adding half the vegetables before baking and half after keeps everything tasting fresh and bright.

Instructions

Cook the chicken low and slow:

Simmer the seasoned chicken breasts in broth until they're tender enough to shred with just two forks.

Shred and coat:

Let the chicken cool slightly, then shred it right in the pan so it soaks up all those spiced juices.

Build your foundation:

Spread those sturdy tortilla chips across your largest baking sheet, leaving no bare spots.

Layer it up:

Evenly distribute the chicken, both cheeses, and half your fresh toppings.

Melt everything together:

Bake until the cheese is bubbly and starting to brown in spots.

Finish fresh:

Top with the remaining vegetables, avocado, and cilantro while everything's still hot.

Pin it

My sister-in-law now requests these for every family movie night, and honestly, I don't mind making them at all. There's something satisfying about watching everyone dig in together, no formal plates required.

Make-Ahead Magic

The pulled chicken can be made up to three days ahead and stored in its cooking liquid. Actually, the flavors get better overnight, so this is perfect for party prep. Just reheat gently before assembling.

Serving Strategy

I learned the hard way that putting out one massive platter creates a bottleneck around the table. Now I make two smaller platters and place them on opposite ends of the room. Everyone gets their food faster, and there's no awkward reaching.

Customization Station

Set up little bowls of extra toppings on the side so everyone can personalize their portion.

• Pickled red onions add this amazing tang that cuts through the rich cheese
• Hot sauce on the side keeps everyone happy regardless of their spice tolerance
• Fresh corn kernels add this perfect sweetness contrast

Pin it

These nachos have turned more quiet gatherings into loud, happy conversations than any other dish I make. Sometimes the messiest food brings the best moments.

Common Recipe Questions

→ How is the chicken prepared for the nachos?

Chicken breasts are simmered gently in a broth with smoked paprika, cumin, chili powder, and other seasonings until tender, then shredded to layer over the chips.

→ What cheeses are used on the nachos?

A blend of shredded cheddar and Monterey Jack cheeses is sprinkled over the chips before baking for a melty, creamy topping.

→ Can these nachos be made gluten-free?

Yes, by using certified gluten-free tortilla chips, the dish can be enjoyed without gluten concerns.

→ What fresh toppings complement the pulled chicken nachos?

Diced red onion, jalapeño slices, tomatoes, black olives, avocado, and chopped cilantro provide fresh, vibrant flavors and textures.

→ Are there alternative options for quicker preparation?

Rotisserie chicken can be substituted to save time, and pepper jack cheese can replace the standard cheeses for extra heat.